| AIR DATES | EPISODE NUMBER | SUMMARY WRITER | EPISODE TITLE |
| October 25, 1999 | AM-301 | Dana | Car Wash |
| November 1, 1999 | AM-302 | Dana | Buried Pleasures |
| November 8, 1999 | AM-303 | Dana | Seeing Green |
| November 15, 1999 | AM-304 | Dana | Heat Wave |
| November 22, 1999 | AM-305 | Josh | Troubled Water |
| November 29, 1999 | AM-306 | Dana | Changes |
| December 6, 1999 | AM-210 | Dana | Making Spirits Bright (R) from Season 2 |
| December 13, 1999 | AM-307 | Dana | Saving Santa |
| December 20, 1999 | AM-308 | Dana | Blue Christmas |
| December 27, 1999 | AM-206 | Dana | You Never Can Tell (R) from Season 2 |
| January 3, 2000 | AM-208 | Dana | Happy Trails (R) from Season 2 |
| January 10, 2000 | AM-309 | Dana | Out in the Cold |
| January 17, 2000 | None | None |
8:00 PM ET
"The Life and Trials of Ally McBeal" Clip show |
| January 17, 2000 | AM-310 | Josh | Just Friends |
| January 24, 2000 | AM-209 | Dana | Just Looking (R) from Season 2 |
| January 31, 2000 | AM-204 | Dana |
8:00 PM ET
It's My Party (R) from Season 2 |
| January 31, 2000 | AM-205 | Dana | Story of Love (R) from Season 2 |
| February 7, 2000 | AM-311 | Dana | Over the Rainbow |
| February 14, 2000 | AM-312 | Josh | In Search of Pygmies |
| February 21, 2000 | AM-313 | Dana | Pursuit of Loneliness |
| February 28, 2000 | AM-314 | Josh | The Oddball Parade |
| March 6, 2000 | AM-306 | Dana | Changes (R) from Season 3 |
| March 13, 2000 | AM-213 | Dana | Angels and Blimps (R) from Season 2 |
| March 20, 2000 | AM-315 | Dana | Prime Suspect |
| March 27, 2000 | AM-316 | Josh | Boy Next Door |
| April 3, 2000 | AM-201 | Dana | The Real World (R) from Season 2 |
| April 10, 2000 | AM-316 | Josh | Boy Next Door (R) from Season 3 |
| April 17, 2000 | AM-317 | Josh | I Will Survive |
| April 24, 2000 | AM-114 | Dana | Body Language (R) from Season 1 |
| May 1, 2000 | AM-318 | Dana | Turning Thirty |
| May 8, 2000 | AM-319 | Josh | Do You Wanna Dance |
| May 15, 2000 | AM-320 | Josh | Hope and Glory |
| May 22, 2000 | AM-321 | Dana | Ally McBeal: The Musical, Almost (Season Finale) |
| May 29, 2000 | AM-301 | Dana | Car Wash (R) from Season 3 |
| June 5, 2000 | AM-304 | Dana | Heat Wave (R) from Season 3 |
| June 12, 2000 | AM-116 | Dana | Forbidden Fruits (R) from Season 1 |
| June 19, 2000 | AM-302 | Dana | Buried Pleasures (R) from Season 3 |
| June 26, 2000 | AM-303 | Dana | Seeing Green (R) from Season 3 |
| July 3, 2000 | AM-207 | Dana | Worlds Without Love (R) from Season 2 |
| July 10, 2000 | AM-309 | Dana | Out in the Cold (R) from Season 3 |
| July 17, 2000 | AM-312 | Josh | In Search of Pygmies (R) from Season 3 |
| July 24, 2000 | AM-313 | Dana | Pursuit of Loneliness (R) from Season 3 |
| July 31, 2000 | AM-314 | Josh | The Oddball Parade (R) from Season 3 |
| August 7, 2000 | AM-315 | Dana | Prime Suspect (R) from Season 3 |
| August 14, 2000 | AM-212 | Dana | Love Unlimited (R) from Season 2 |
| August 21, 2000 | AM-120 | Dana | The Inmates (R) from Season 1 |
| August 28, 2000 | AM-122 | Dana | Alone Again (R) from Season 1 |
| September 4, 2000 | AM-118 | Dana | 8pm ET The Playing Field (R) from Season 1 |
| September 4, 2000 | AM-119 | Dana | Happy Birthday, Baby (R) from Season 1 |
| September 11, 2000 | AM-123 | Dana | These are the Days (R) from Season 1 |