Written by David E. Kelley
Directed by Arlene Sanford

Guest starring

Albert Hall as Judge Walsh
Gerry Becker as Stone
Dakin Matthews as Stark
Peter Mackenzie as Stevens

Special guest star Marlo Thomas as Lynnie

and Jami Gertz as Kimmy Bishop

Co-starring

Emmett Shoemaker as Jacob Ray
Sara Van Horn as jury forewoman

Featured music

"Winter Wonderland" performed by Macy Gray (carrying the tree)
"It's Not Unusual" by Tom Jones (Richard's demo for John)
"Tomorrow" from "Annie," performed by Jane Krakowski (Elaine practicing and performing)
"Christmas is Coming" traditional English performed by Calista Flockhart (trying to find a song for Larry)
"All I Want for Christmas is My Two Front Teeth" by Don Gardner performed by Calista Flockhart (trying to find a song for Larry)
"Jingle Bells" by James Pierpont performed by Calista Flockhart (trying to find a song for Larry)
"River" by Joni Mitchell, performed by Robert Downey Jr. (Ally goes to the bathroom)
"Treat Her Right" by Roy Head (Richard's suggestion and John's performance)
"White Christmas" by Irving Berlin (Ally and Larry in her apartment at the end)