Written by David E. Kelley
Directed by Billy Dickson

Guest starring

Tom Berenger as Father Harrison Wyatt
Peter Scolari as Mr. Houle
Charles Martin Smith as mayor
Albert Hall as Judge Seymore Walsh
Christopher Neiman as Attorney Barry Mathers
Josh Groban as Malcolm Wyatt
Craig Anton
Ron Ostrow

Co-starring

Renee Goldsberry, Vatrena King, Sy Smith as singers

Featured music

"Someday at Christmas" by Stevie Wonder, performed by Vonda (opening song)
"Jingle Bells" written by James Pierpoint, performed by Vonda (first song after credits)
"Rock and Roll Christmas", originally by James Thorogood and the Destroyers, performed by Jane K. & James M. (Elaine & Glenn practicing)
"Jingle Bell Rock" originally by Bobby Helms, performed by Vonda (just before John dresses like an elf)
"Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" originally by Judy Garland, performed by Vonda (Ally goes to talk to the son)
"Santa Claus Got Stuck In My Chimney" performed by Jane K. (Elaine doesn't let Glenn sing)
"Joy to the World" written by Watts and Handel, performed by some British punk group (just before Mayor's testimony)
"Warm and Fuzzy" originally by Billy Gilman, performed by Jane K. & James M. (Elaine & Glenn's second duet)
"One Little Christmas Tree" by Stevie Wonder, performed by Vonda (Ally decorating her tree)
"Let It Snow!" written by Cahn and Styne, performed by Vonda (after John's closing)
"What Christmas Means to Me" by Stevie Wonder, performed by Vonda & Jane K. (beginning of Xmas party at the bar)
"To Where You Are" by Josh Groban (ending song)